| The Ocean | 59 | Bloop Fish · up to 1,679,832 C$ |
| Atlantis | 49 | Deep Emperor · up to 262,500 C$ |
| Admin Events | 44 | Admin Crate · up to 31 C$ |
| Roslit Bay | 33 | Aetherfin · up to 126,000 C$ |
| Ancient Isle | 30 | Livyatan · up to 128,067 C$ |
| Treasure Island | 19 | Gem Blobfish · up to 168,000 C$ |
| Moosewood | 18 | Cataclysm Carp · up to 126,000 C$ |
| Sunstone Island | 18 | Crustal Colossus · up to 126,000 C$ |
| The Depths | 17 | Ancient Depth Serpent · up to 21,704 C$ |
| Drylands | 16 | Terrosunder · up to 94,070 C$ |
| Lost Jungle | 16 | Paradox Piranha · up to 447,300 C$ |
| Mushgrove Swamp | 16 | Handfish · up to 15,085 C$ |
| Forsaken Shores | 15 | Pirate Captain's Goldfish · up to 63,196 C$ |
| Toxic Grove | 15 | Witherbloom · up to 111,353 C$ |
| Desolate Deep | 14 | Lumilotl · up to 447,300 C$ |
| Fischgiving 2025 | 14 | — |
| Winter Village | 14 | Santa Pufferfish · up to 4,800 C$ |
| Ethereal Abyss Pool | 13 | Starlit Weaver · up to 1,680 C$ |
| LEGO® Event 2025 | 13 | Glow Brick · up to 1,676 C$ |
| Snowcap Island | 13 | Ringle · up to 2,250 C$ |
| Crowned Ruins | 12 | Blackmouth Catshark · up to 10,500 C$ |
| Waveborne | 12 | Gale Snapper · up to 621 C$ |
| Everturn Forest | 11 | Floraseer Sturgeon · up to 10,930 C$ |
| Sunken Reliquary | 11 | Awakened Omnithal · up to 402,570 C$ |
| Tidefall | 11 | Forbidden Plesiosaur · up to 143,640 C$ |
| Fischfest 2 | 10 | Beached Relic · up to 15,000 C$ |
| Poseidon Trial Pool | 10 | Deep Emperor · up to 262,500 C$ |
| Roslit Volcano | 10 | Molten Banshee · up to 16,500 C$ |
| Terrapin Island | 10 | Manatee · up to 5,250 C$ |
| Abyssal Zenith | 9 | Giant Seadevil · up to 22,962 C$ |
| Atlantean Storm | 9 | Dusky Blobfish · up to 3,255,021 C$ |
| Brine Pool | 9 | Caustic Starwyrm · up to 91,476 C$ |
| Castaway Cliffs | 9 | Scalloped Hammerhead · up to 43,464 C$ |
| Collapsed Ruins | 9 | Black Scabbardfish · up to 8,988 C$ |
| Coral Bastion | 9 | Reef Titan · up to 260,925 C$ |
| Cultist Lair | 9 | — |
| Cursed Isle | 9 | Abyssborn Monstrosity · up to 48,252 C$ |
| Enchanted Crevice | 9 | Sovereign Oarfish · up to 11,053 C$ |
| Frightful Village | 9 | — |
| Northern Expedition (Cryogenic Canal) | 9 | Glacial Sturgeon · up to 17,500 C$ |
| Sunken Depths Pool | 9 | Atlantean Guardian · up to 269 C$ |
| Carrot Garden | 8 | Carrot Snapper · up to 6,706 C$ |
| Crimson Cavern | 8 | Colossal Ancient Dragon · up to 525,000 C$ |
| Cults Curse | 8 | The Whispering One · up to 32,100 C$ |
| Emberreach | 8 | Obsidian Koi · up to 5,303 C$ |
| FischFright 2025 | 8 | Frightful Relic · up to 1,000 C$ |
| Grand Reef | 8 | Grand Reef Guardian · up to 21,350 C$ |
| Open Ocean | 8 | Magician Narwhal · up to 2,100,000 C$ |
| Veil of the Forsaken | 8 | Twilight Tentaclefish · up to 287,907 C$ |
| Anniversary 2025 | 7 | Birthday Cake · up to 32,723 C$ |
| Calm Zone | 7 | Shimmering Silverside · up to 16,317 C$ |
| Challenger's Deep | 7 | — |
| Glacial Grotto | 7 | Shiverfin Haddock · up to 1,151 C$ |
| Luminescent Cavern | 7 | Bluelip Batfish · up to 105 C$ |
| Vertigo | 7 | Rubber Ducky · up to 1,801 C$ |
| Boreal Pines | 6 | Frostwyrm · up to 148,500 C$ |
| Crystal Cove | 6 | Crystal Lobster · up to 16,799,958 C$ |
| Frightful Pool | 6 | Nessie · up to 15,322 C$ |
| Hall of Whispers | 6 | — |
| Isle of New Beginnings | 6 | Phantom Koi · up to 100,184 C$ |
| Keepers Altar | 6 | Umbral Shark · up to 2,321 C$ |
| Kraken Pool | 6 | Abyssal King · up to 12,932 C$ |
| Lushgrove | 6 | Primordial Levi · up to 89,460 C$ |
| Mariana's Veil (Volcanic Vents) | 6 | Magma Leviathan · up to 53,580 C$ |
| New Year's Pool | 6 | Eonshell · up to 42,525 C$ |
| Northern Expedition (Overgrowth Caves) | 6 | Frozen Walnut · up to 6,918 C$ |
| Above The Clouds | 5 | Wyvern · up to 64,050 C$ |
| Admin event - Aliens | 5 | Alien Buddy · up to 280,000 C$ |
| Ancient Archives | 5 | Diplurus · up to 670 C$ |
| Anywhere | 5 | Him · up to 10,500 C$ |
| Bellona's Frenzy of War | 5 | Legionnaire Lamprey · up to 62,948 C$ |
| Frightful Pools | 5 | — |
| Frigid Cavern | 5 | Polar Alligator · up to 3,988 C$ |
| Living Garden | 5 | Toxic Guardian · up to 115,469 C$ |
| Passage of Oaths | 5 | — |
| Regionless | 5 | Seraphfin · up to 126,000 C$ |
| Scoria Reach | 5 | Igneous Pearl · up to 18,900 C$ |
| Second Sea | 5 | Phantom Koi · up to 100,184 C$ |
| The Mineshaft | 5 | Crystal Geode · up to 8,400 C$ |
| Trick-or-Treat | 5 | — |
| Animal Event | 4 | Mained Lionfish · up to 13,650 C$ |
| Atlantis (Kraken Pool) | 4 | Ancient Kraken · up to 92,400 C$ |
| Azure Lagoon | 4 | Verdant Mirage · up to 52,500 C$ |
| None | 4 | Admin Bait Crate · up to 30,500 C$ |
| Northern Expedition (Frigid Cavern) | 4 | Ice Jellyfish · up to 560 C$ |
| Northstar Castle | 4 | Northstar Whale · up to 73,500 C$ |
| Sunken Depths | 4 | Oracle Minnow · up to 107 C$ |
| The Sanctum | 4 | Cave Angel Fish · up to 17,166 C$ |
| Volcanic Vents | 4 | Pyrite Pufferfish · up to 2,755 C$ |
| Zeus's Rod Room | 4 | Voltfin Carp · up to 9,360 C$ |
| (Winters Edge) | 3 | Glacier Glowfish · up to 3,780 C$ |
| Anywhere during an CORRUPTION admin event | 3 | Corrupted Megalodon · up to 750,000 C$ |
| Fischmas 2025 | 3 | — |
| Golden Tide Pools | 3 | Eternal Frostwhale · up to 32,009 C$ |
| Mariana's Veil (Challenger's Deep) | 3 | Frozen Leviathan · up to 37,809 C$ |
| Northern Expedition (Glacial Grotto) | 3 | Icebeard Shark · up to 18,730 C$ |
| Octophant Hunt | 3 | Octophant · up to 94,500 C$ |
| Roslit Bay (Ashfall 2025) | 3 | — |
| Snowburrow | 3 | Penguin · up to 7,515 C$ |
| Snowcap Pond | 3 | Burbot · up to 81 C$ |
| The Ocean (Shark Hunt Event) | 3 | Great White Shark · up to 15,000 C$ |
